Hammer Drill vs. Rotary Hammer: Tool Test

If you need to travel a screw into cement, you’ve acquired two alternatives. Either you make use of a sizable rotary hammer or perhaps a drill driver having a hammer-drill function.

Both resources pound the little bit while it spins, pulverizing concrete, nevertheless the two differ inside the components which do the particular pounding.

In a rotary hammer, a cylinder of atmosphere is compressed with a piston, which surpasses the little bit. In a hammer drill, two ribbed metallic discs click on out and in against each other, causing influence.

Between tradesmen functioning everyday, rotary hammers are favored because of their superior strength and jolt-absorbing characteristics. For your infrequent end user, the big, cumbersome tools tend to be overkill—a powerful all-goal drill car owner using a hammer-drill setting makes much more sense.

Rockwell, producers from the JawHorse, released its new H3 Hammer Drill at this particular January’s Global Builders’ Present. The H3 is actually a 12-volt rotary hammer which is about the size of a standard 18-volt drill. (It really is engineered as a rotary hammer, but for some reason Rockwell telephone calls it a hammer drill).

Within my experience, 12-volt drills are great enough for modifying hinges and other light- duty tasks, not one which incorporate drilling through cement. I had my concerns relating to this one.

So where does the H3 remain from the traditional hammer drill and rotary hammer? Can a junior-varsity-size device compete with the pros?

To discover, I simulated some actual- community apps, looking at the tools for battery lifestyle and power.

The hammer drill I found in the exams was the 18-volt Makita BHP452, and the rotary hammer was actually a 1-in . Bosch Bulldog 11255VSR.

54) Battery Life

To test battery life, I set a piece of 3⁄4-in. plywood on a couple of concrete prevents, then drilled and drove 13⁄4-” cement screws to the wooden until the battery packs on each tool died. The screws which I utilized needed a 5⁄32-in. pilot hole, therefore I equipped each device with a brand new Bosch bit.

First up was the H3. The mini-tool managed to sink 11 cement screws and drilled out your hole for that twelfth prior to the electric battery gone down.

Because the tool comes with a fast-alter car owner tad, transitioning from drilling to driving was easy. In addition, I timed the test, and also the H3 did all of this in exactly 7 minutes.

Not surprisingly, the 18-volt Makita outdistanced the H3. In reality, a while during minute 15, I started to ponder if it would ever end. Around the second 20, I started praying it would. At 23: 03, the battery finally moved deceased (as do the sensation inside my right arm).

In that time, I drilled and drove 36 concrete screws and was halfway with the opening for No. 37.

Since the Makita has a normal three-jaw chuck, swapping the drill bit out for that car owner was tiresome and painful. Since I’m inside the habit of loosening the chuck by gripping it and providing the tool some liquid, once I was carried out, your skin layer in my palm was rosy red and felt like I had just grabbed a hot cattle brand name. 30-six bit alter-outs is to consider.

So, arm stress and hand discomfort apart, the Makita was the very clear winner in the electric battery- existence classification. However I got a closer look on the results and found another thing that’s intriguing.

If you do the mathematics to learn just how long each instrument had taken to drive just one screw (divide the minutes from the screw overall), the outcomes are nearly identical, having a minor advantage coming to the H3: 38.2 seconds for your Makita and 38.3 mere seconds for the H3. And so the H3 can sprint alongside the hammer drill, it simply can’t operate the marathon.

Brute Pressure

Interested by these outcomes, I established the timer for 3 a few minutes. I counted the number of fifty percent- inch slots each unit could punch from the 13⁄4-inch wall structure of a cement obstruct within that 180-2nd span.

Once again, the H3 was first up. Within the allotted time, the small device drilled 8 slots, which translates to one every 20 secs.

The Makita only managed to drill six holes within the concrete block. It punched a single opening every thirty seconds. Despite the short period of time, my hands and arm felt the abuse in the tool’s rattle.

To acquire a sense of how effective a full- dimension rotary hammer is, I added my corded Bosch Bulldog for the examination. The 2- handed device, in a show of pure, unrelenting energy, smashed 40 slots in the cinder block in 3 minutes—one every 4.5 seconds. And take into account that the model I have is in the little part for rotary hammers.

Main Point Here

Where performs this check information put the H3, in framework featuring its competition? In a pretty good area, I’d say. The truth that this 12-volt instrument could exceed the 18-volt inside the strength section speaks to the mechanized advantage of the rotary-hammer system.

Unfortunately, all of that hammering requires its toll on the life of the battery. That’s where the instrument suffers. But when you only need to drill and push a single concrete anchor—or lower than eleven—the H3 can handle the work.

If you are in search of more rotary hammer drill reviews you should check out Youtube or go to your local store and ask them to show you how they perform!

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Reply